Theirs Not to Reason Why (3 player) ETO (id:#62542)
Chapel Hill, Crimea
1941-12-19 (9 others)
A 90: Cutting Out a Strongpoint (AH:ASL Annual `95 Winter)
MLR 1: Hana-Saku (Maple Leaf Route # 1.1)
MLR 1: Hana-Saku (Canada at War)
MLR 1: Hana-Saku (View From the Trenches # 32)
WG 9: Retreat from Moscow (Wargamer # 2.11)
MLR01: Hana-Saku (Elite Canadians)
DB104: The Police Station (Dispatches from the Bunker #36)
J166: Maximum Aggression (ASL Journal #11)
267: Cutting Out a Strongpoint (ASL 7a - Hollow Legions (3rd Edition))
MLR 1: Hana-Saku (Maple Leaf Route # 1.1)
MLR 1: Hana-Saku (Canada at War)
MLR 1: Hana-Saku (View From the Trenches # 32)
WG 9: Retreat from Moscow (Wargamer # 2.11)
MLR01: Hana-Saku (Elite Canadians)
DB104: The Police Station (Dispatches from the Bunker #36)
J166: Maximum Aggression (ASL Journal #11)
267: Cutting Out a Strongpoint (ASL 7a - Hollow Legions (3rd Edition))
Designer: Mike Augustine
Starter kit scenario?: Deluxe scenario?:
Balance:
German / RomanianRussian
Overview:
Knight’s Cross recipient, Brigadier General Mihail Lascăr leads his Romanian infantry and German allies to clear the Russian 7th Naval Infantry Brigade from a hilltop bastion near the port of Sevastopol. . . .Has two sets of VCs (and special instruction SSR#4) so it can be played either as a 2-player or a 3-player scenario. Although Germans and Romanians are somewhat cooperative, only one axis force can win (assuming the Russians don't win).Attacker: German / Romanian (German 105th Inf Rgmt, Sturmgeschuetz-Abt. 190, and Romanian 1st Mtn Bde)
Defender: Russian (7th Naval Infantry Brigade)
5.5 turns
Players: 2 OBA: Russian Night: No| Unit Counts: |
| Squads: A:15.0 D:9.0 |
| AFVs: A:1 StuG IIIB |
| AFVs: D:2 T-26 M33 T-26 M33 |
| Guns: A:2 Brandt M27/31 D:0 75mm Skoda M14/34 ART PzB 39 ATR Ur wz. 35 ATR x 2 50mm RM obr. 40 PTRD-41 ATR |
| Misc Rules: | Can be played as Three player. |
| Map Board(s): |
| Overlays: | NONE |
Errata (source)
Players wanting to play this game/Request a match:
Scenario info
Last Played:
| Date | Reporter | Opponent | Bal. | Result | Time | Comments | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022-02-19 | (D) Dan Best | vs | Kermit Mullins Dave Mareske | German / Romanian win | |||
| 2022-02-19 | (A) Dave Mareske | vs | Dan Best, Scott Mullins | German / Romanian win | Heavy SMOKE made way for a quick German advance, but the Romanians got pinned down by some mortar fire and the 10-2 being killed by the Russian sniper before he even moved. Lost the FT on the first shot and a DC rolled a 12 trying to take out a WIRE. The Naval OBA destroyed the 75 ART but was inaccurate the rest of the game. Turn 2 brought a slower advance with the Germans moving slowing allowing their armor to catch up and the Romanians trying to regroup. The Russians came on the west edge giving the reinforcements to the Romanians. By Turn 3 the Germans secured the first hill but were broken and had to retreat to regroup. The Romanian mortar was a thorn in the Russian side the whole game, getting ROF several times and scoring one CH and avoiding the NOBA with a little luck. The axis sniper was able to kill the Russian 9-1 leader and break a couple of squads by the end of Turn 3. By turn 4 it was a race for hill locations and in the end the Germans had the edge getting 10 to the Romanian 7. Good game, but very hard on the Russians to defend the hill. Setting up a reverse slope defense in some places might have been better. | ||
| 2022-02-19 | (A) Kermit Mullins | vs | Dan Best | German / Romanian win | |||
| 2015-10-10 | (D) Jason Wert | vs | Cliff Welsh | Russian win |
| Action | Date |
|---|---|
| Hutch Modified the Attacker's Guns | 2024-10-20 14:31:13 |
| Hutch Modified the Defender's Guns | 2024-10-20 14:31:13 |
| Hutch Modified the unit counts | 2024-10-20 14:29:40 |
| Hutch Modified the Defender's AFVs | 2024-10-20 14:29:40 |
| Hutch Modified the Attacker's Guns | 2024-10-20 14:29:40 |
| File | Description | User | Views |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mihail Lascăr (lascar.png) | Image | hoxson1 | 1046 |
| (germ vs roman vs soviet.png) | Image | hoxson1 | 891 |
| (theirs not to map.png) | Map Image | hoxson1 | 793 |
| Description | Uploaded by |
|---|
| Title | Author | Date |
|---|
| Description | Uploaded by |
|---|
Quick Map View
Location
Images
Mihail Lascăr
| Statistics: | |
| Avg Rating: 6.60 | Votes: 5 |
| Views: | 4944 |
| To-Play list count: | 1 |
| Estimated Play time: | 4.4 hours |
| Recorded Games: | 2 |
| Archive recorded plays: | ||
| German / Romanian | 1 | |
| Russian | 1 | |
| Drawn: | 0 | |
| ROAR Data: (as of today) Theirs Not to Reason Why (three player) [Log in to Confirm or Edit] |
| [A] German | 3 |
| [D] Romanian | 2 |